Mary's Diner

Geneva Location 
Facebook Icon
Madison Location 
Facebook Icon

(440) 466-6393

Hours of Operation
Monday – Sunday, 6:00 a.m. – 8:00 p.m.

Free Wi-Fi Available


Lunch and Dinner

Nacho Fries

Golden crispy fries smothered with chili, cheddar, jalapeno, olives, chopped tomatoes, and sour cream — $5.99

Jumbo Wings

Plain, Buffalo, BBQ, Garlic, or Ranch
3 Pounds — $15.99
1 1/2 Pounds — $7.99
Snack Size — $3.99

Mozzarella Sticks

Deep fried and served with marinara — $5.99

Appetizer Sampler

Chicken tenders, cheese sticks, onion rings, deep-fried mushrooms, and mac-n-cheese dippers. Served with marinara and ranch dipping sauce — $12.99

Bacon Mac-n-Cheese Dippers

Deep fried gooey goodness! — $5.99

Frito Pie

Crumbled Fritos smothered with chili and topped with cheddar and sour cream — $4.99


All kinds of melted bliss inside a grilled tortilla — $5.99
Add chicken — $7.99

Potato Skins

Stuffed to the top with bacon and cheddar cheese — $5.99

Deep Fried Mushrooms — $5.99

Soups and Salads


A dinner staple.
Bowl — $3.99
Cup — $2.99

Soup of the Day

Ask your server.
Bowl — $3.49
Cup — $2.49

Chicken Club Salad

Grilled chicken breast, crispy bacon, veggies, and cheese on a bed of iceberg lettuce — $8.99

Steak Salad

Tender seasoned steak on a bed of lettuce, tomato, onion, and cheddar cheese. Stacked high with crispy French fries — $9.99

The Portabella Supreme

Grilled portabella mushrooms tossed together with walnuts, Mandarin oranges, roasted red peppers, black olives, tomatoes, and bleu cheese crumbles on a bed of lettuce — $10.99

Taco Salad

Seasoned taco meat over lettuce. Topped with diced onions, jalapenos, tomatoes, black olives, cheddar cheese, sour cream, and salsa in a giant taco bowl — $8.99

Chef Salad

Generous portions of turkey and ham, hard-boiled egg, cheddar cheese, onions, and tomatoes atop crisp iceberg lettuce — $8.99

Cool Platter

Choice of tuna or chicken salad, fruit, and cottage cheese surrounded by garden veggies — $7.99

Spinach Salad

Fresh baby spinach leaves, veggies, and eggs covered in a warm, sweet bacon dressing — $7.99
Add chicken — $8.99

Blackened Salmon Salad

A tender salmon filet dusted with Cajun seasoning and grilled.  Placed atop a bed of baby spinach, tomato, eggs, onion, and cheddar cheese — $10.99


Funky Chicken

All served with golden crispy fries.

Chicken Bacon Ranch Sub

Grilled chicken breast tenders topped with crispy bacon, melted provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, and creamy ranch dressing — $7.99

Grilled Chicken Wrap

Grilled chicken breast, lettuce, tomatoes, and cheddar cheese — $7.99

Buffalo Chicken Wrap

Golden, fried chicken tenders drenched in Buffalo sauce. Wrapped up with lettuce, tomatoes, and cheddar cheese — $7.99

Chicken Parmesan Sub

Crispy, fried chicken tenders covered in provolone and marinara on a toasted sub bun — $7.99

Restaurant Interior

Mary's Original Big Bopper Burgers

Jumbo Cheeseburger

"Gladly pay you Tuesday for a hamburger today." — $7.99

Mary's Classic

Our classic double-decker cheeseburger with special sauce and lettuce. You won't forget it! — $8.99

Plate of Burger and Fries

Ragin' Cajun Burger

Cajun—spiced burger topped with deep-fried jalapenos, chipolte mayo, and cheddar cheese — $8.99

Backyard BBQ Burger

A jumbo patty, smoked bacon, and cheddar cheese. Topped off with hickory BBQ sauce and crispy fried onion tanglers — $9.99


Two juicy burgers, grilled salami, provolone, tomatoes, lettuce, and onions. Marinated in Italian spices and served on a toasted sub bun — $8.99

What's Shakin' Bacon Burger

4 thick cut pieces of bacon with your choice of cheese — $9.99

Stacked Bacon Mac Burger

Deep fried Mac-n-Cheese Dippers on top of an Angus patty with your choice of cheese — $9.99

Mushroom Swiss Burger

Loaded with mushrooms and topped with Swiss cheese — $8.99


Love Me Tender Chicken Basket

Tasty chicken tenders with a basket of fries — $7.99

Shrimp Basket

Panko-breaded shrimp in a basket of fries — $8.99

Foot-Long Hot Dog

With golden crispy fries — $5.99
Add chili or sauerkraut — $0.50

Lake Erie Perch Sandwich

Fillet of perch, straight from the lake, with lettuce and tomatoes — $9.99

Brat Basket

Old-world bratwurst on a toasted bun served with fries — $7.99

Egg Salad Croissant

Creamy and delicious, served with chips — $6.99

Melts and More

Bella Melt

Grilled portabella mushroom topped with roasted red peppers and bleu cheese crumbles — $8.49


Corned beef stacked high, layered with sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, and Mary's dressing — $8.99

Pot Roast Melt

Savory pot roast piled high with cheddar cheese — $8.99

Meatloaf Melt

A thick slice of Mary's homemade recipe — $8.49

Charlie Tuna Melt

All-white meat tuna salad and American cheese on toast — $7.99

Club Sandwich

Tukey, ham, bacon, and cheese three layers high — $8.99

Grilled Chicken Sandwich

A grilled chicken breast on a corn-dusted roll with lettuce and tomatoes — $7.99

Patty Duke Melt

Two burgers with grilled onion on toasted rye. Topped with meled Swiss cheese and Mary's dressing — $8.99

Three Cheese Melt

Cheddar, American, and Swiss cheeses divide two pieces of Texas toast — $6.99
Add bacon and tomato — $7.99

Spicy Chicken Sandwich

Golden fried chicken tenders marinated in a spicy sauce with provolone cheese — $7.99

Open-Faced Turkey or Pot Roast Sandwich

Roasted turkey or juicy pot roast smothered in gravy with a side of mashed potatoes — $8.99

Grilled Ham and Swiss

Ham and Swiss cheese on buttery grilled Texas toast — $7.99

Philly Steak Sandwich

Mushrooms, onions, cheese, and roasted peppers — $8.49


A Diner classic. Served with chips — $6.99

Dinner at the Diner

All dinners include one side and choice of potato (*unless otherwise noted).

Mary's Home-Style Meatloaf

Juicy, hot, delicious.  Just like Mom used to make. — $9.99

Pot Roast Dinner

Savory, fall-apart pot roast. Famous the World over! — $10.99

Pork Chops

Two center—cut chops breaded or grilled — $10.99

Apple Glazed Pork Chops

Two grilled chops seasoned to perfection, toped with a rich apple butter glaze — $11.99

Butter Crumb Cod

Twin peaks of fresh cod topped with a special butter crumb topping, seasoned and broiled to a golden brown — $11.99

Lake Erie Yellow Perch

Deep—fried lake perch served with tartar sauce — $15.99

Fresh Chicken Tenders

Two huge chicken breast tenders beer—battered and fried golden brown — $9.99

Pierogis and Kielbasa*

Grilled onions atop a huge portion of potato and cheese pierogis and sliced kielbasa — $10.99

Grilled Chicken Breast

Butterflied and charbroiled chicken breast— $8.99

Spaghetti and Meatballs*

Two huge meatballs on a mountain of pasta covered in marinara. Served with garlic bread — $8.99

Creamed Chicken Over Biscuits

Buttermilk biscuits smothered in a creamy gravy with tender chicken and veggies — $9.99

Oh My Cod

A giant piece of beer-battered mild fish served with choice of potato and salad — $9.99

Chopped Sirloin

Grilled sirloin smothered with mushrooms and onions then topped with brown gravy — $9.99

Country Fried Steak Dinner

Crispy country fried steak and mashed potatoes topped with creamy country gravy — $9.99

New York Strip Steak

Charbroiled and served with your choice of potato — $16.99

Smokehouse Chicken

A grilled chicken breast covered with bacon, cheddar cheese, and smokey BBQ sauce — $10.99

Cincinnati Chili*

A huge pile of spaghetti covered in our famous homemade chili. Topped off with diced onions and cheddar cheese — $8.99

Chicken Alfredo*

Grilled chicken breast tossed in our signature alfredo sauce. Served over noodles with garlic bread — $11.99

Fried Chicken Dinner

Three golden fried pieces of honey—touched chicken — $11.99

Chicken Parmigiana*

Blanketed with rich marinara, provolone, and parmesan. Includes a side of pasta and garlic bread— $10.99

Teriyaki Salmon

A flaky, grilled salmon filet with a teriyaki glaze — $12.99

Buffalo Chicken Mac n Cheese*

Gooey mac n cheese topped with crispy chicken tenders drenched in buffalo sauce and a creamy ranch drizzle — $9.99


*Some sides are available for an upcharge.

  • Macaroni and Cheese — $2.99
  • Golden Crispy Fries — $2.99
  • Sweet Potato Fries* — $3.99
  • Veggie of the Day — $1.79
  • "Nat King" Coleslaw — $1.99
  • Baked Potato — $2.99
  • Baked Sweet Potato — $2.99
  • "Do the" Mashed Potato and Gravy — $1.99
  • Onion Rings* — $3.99
  • Fire Roasted Quinoa — $2.99
  • Salad — $2.99
  • Cottage Cheese — $1.99
  • Applesauce — $1.79

Kids' Menu

Kids' menu for children 10 and under only.

Before the Swing

Mickey Mouse Pancake — $2.99
Add two pieces of bacon or one piece of sausage — $3.99
French Toast Sticks — $2.99
Add two pieces of bacon or one piece of sausage — $3.99

After the Sandbox

Gidget's Grilled Cheese Triangles and Fries — $2.99
Meatloaf and Mashed Potatoes — $3.99
Kids' Size Cheese Pizza — $2.99
Spaghetti and Meatball — $3.99
Corn Dog and Fries — $2.99

Kids' Klassic

One egg with hash browns and toast — $1.99
Add two pieces of bacon or one piece of sausage — $2.99

Kountry Kids

One biscuit and gravy with one scrambled egg — $2.99

Small Fry Baskets

Wimpy Burger with Fries — $3.99
Chicken Little Fingers and Fries — $3.99
Fish Sticks and Fries — $3.99
Hot Dog and Fries — $2.99
Kids' Soft Drink — $0.99